Former England captain Alastair Cook has questioned how Australia’s celebrated bowling quartet could have remained oblivious to the sandpaper scandal, revealing how England’s entire team was once schooled in the art of reverse swing by Pakistan legend Mushtaq Ahmed.


Writing in The Sunday Times, Cook said the meticulous attention cricketers pay to the condition of the ball made it difficult to accept that Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Nathan Lyon knew nothing about what was happening in Cape Town in 2018.


“I find it just really hard to believe half the team didn’t know,” Cook wrote.

The Ashes winning captain  offered a fascinating insight into England’s dressing room during their rise to the top of the Test rankings, when Mushtaq, their spin bowling coach until 2014, passed on the secrets he had learnt playing alongside reverse swing masters Wasim Akram and Waqar Younis.

Mushtaq’s golden rule was simple: keep moisture away from the rough side while relentlessly polishing the shiny side.

“He told us the most crucial thing was not allowing any moisture on to the rougher side of the ball,” Cook recalled.

England took the science so seriously that special team meetings were held to discuss ball maintenance. Every player had a responsibility.

Monty Panesar was even instructed to stop his habit of spinning the ball between his hands because sweat could compromise the rough surface.

Cook, who rarely sweated, became the designated ball polisher, usually operating from mid-off. James Anderson was the other trusted custodian.

“If someone did something out of the normal we would know about it,” Cook explained.

Mushtaq warned that even a little sweat could undo two overs of painstaking work.

Against that background, Cook finds the Australian bowlers’ denials particularly difficult to swallow.

“After two seconds of roughing a ball up with sandpaper everyone would know it was different,” he argued.

Cook also pointed to Mitchell Marsh’s uncomfortable interview this week as evidence of the difficult position in which Australian players now find themselves.

He revisited the 2017-18 Ashes, when Australia demolished England 4-0, recalling the extraordinary reverse swing generated by Starc at Perth, including the delivery that dismissed James Vince.

Usman Khawaja has since alleged that Australia manipulated the quarter seam during that series, although Cook remains unconvinced how much difference that particular method made.

Nevertheless, he stressed that sandpaper crossed a line that conventional ball maintenance never should.

Cook believes the scandal cannot be laid entirely at the doors of David Warner, Steve Smith and Cameron Bancroft, whose careers were devastated by their punishments.

He is not demanding retrospective bans for Australia’s bowlers, but believes collective responsibility is overdue.

“It’s hard to see how this all ends if Cricket Australia doesn’t reopen an investigation or if everyone confesses what they know,” he wrote.

His final argument was particularly pointed: the three punished players might find some consolation if Australia finally acknowledged they had not acted alone.